The new build - The Alyen’s
So, I’ve begun working on 1 of my 2 new builds for MWAF. This is going to be a 4-way design (I mean...why not?) in a moderately sized tower. The main interesting piece of this build is that it is built around an Ultimax 8” subwoofer. So, to start this first post off right, I decided to share some nice 8” flex. Enjoy:
P.s. - I guess the forum video player won’t play in slow-mo but you can scrub through frame by frame and see these babies flex!
I’m excited about it for sure! My only complaint so far is the efficiency... the setup would match so much better if it had about 3 more dB but it is what it is. I tossed around the idea of two per speaker but $$$ and cabinet size just would not allow it.
Are you using a separate amplifier for the subwoofer? Or are you going to run it as a traditional three way? I have always like Definitive Technology and Golden ear, where they power the sub separately, but you still hook it up via normal speaker wire. There are some advantages to this. One being you have more adjustability of the loudness of the bass depending on seating distance and another, is of course, making the top half of the speaker more efficient. In this case you wouldn't need nearly as much power to get the top half to an decent listening level. But this comes all at a drawback...cost.
Well, since these are going to be my Dayton Audio entry for the MWAF speaker building contest, I think I have to run them as a typical single input setup (correct me if I’m wrong). However, that is a good idea for long term setup. Now you’ve got me thinking...
I am not sure about that. I think it just needs to be the drivers that are Dayton. I don't think an amplifier would make much of a difference. And assuming you use the subwoofer amplifier variable crossover with volume, you would still hook it up via normal speaker wire. I can ask a few people at PE if you would like.
Yeah, why don’t you see what you can find out. I could be wrong but I thought only the “open unlimited” could have additional amplification or active crossover/DSP etc... let me know what you find out. I appreciate it!
These were the rules for 2019. Wish they'd get 2020's up for those who would like to participate, if there are any changes.
Yeah, I read those. I take that to mean that speakers with separate amplification will be in the open unlimited category...but maybe I’m wrong.
That's my take also. Somewhere else it explains the gear used for the non-powered categories, amp, source, etc.
The problem that I am having, is you really do not have an active speaker. Granted the subwoofer is active, but the speaker itself is not. And you would still hook it up the same way as a passive speaker. You are probably right that it'll knock itself into the open unlimited, but I am curious, since none really define this type of setup. But I guess that is exactly what open unlimited says. I'll still ask an engineer I know at Parts Express that helps run the competition to see if he has run across this or what they would categorize it.
Here's the playlist on YouTube for MWAF 2019 . When they update, I'll compile the new one, if it has changed.
My understanding (from conversations on the TT forum) is that if it requires power in any form, it's in the "unlimited class". It must be completely passive to qualify for the other classes. It's been a couple of years since I've participated, so perhaps the rules have changed.
First of all, great to see you back! I don't want to hijack the thread, but wanted to get that out there. As far as the competition goes, that stinks. I like the idea of doing a lot of smaller builds with powered subwoofers built in. But I don't think a lot of them when do real well in the open unlimited class. Although I've always been a fan of speakers like golden ear.